소리마당 학술
IRB 심의 관련. EMBC-2015 Biomedical Signal Processing 세션 논문 전수 조사 결과
파란나라 (비회원)
앞서 IRB 심의 및 면제에 관련해서 여러 의견이 올라 왔습니다.
IRB 심의 면제에 대해서도 IRB 심의 면제 번호를 받아야 한다는 의견도 있었고, 심의 면제 번호를 받을 필요가 없다는 의견도 나왔습니다.
한국은 다를 수도 있지만 기본적으로 IRB 면제 여부는 IRB에서만 판단할 수 있다는 의견도 나왔고, 인간 대상 실험은 어떤 분야든 IRB에 문의를 하고 진행하는 것이 옳다는 의견도 나왔습니다.
그리고 EMBC 2015의 논문 제출 가이드라인에 인체/동물 실험은 기관 자체의 IRB 심의/면제 결과를 논문에 기입하도록 되어 있었다는 저의 의견과, 그럼에도 불구하고 인체 생리 신호 측정 결과를 신호 처리하여 분석하는 분야에서 Ack.에 IRB 심의/면제를 적은 걸 본 기억이 없다는 저의 의견도 올라 왔습니다.
이 부분의 논란을 정리하기 위해, EMBC-2015에서 김모씨가 제 1 저자로 발표한 Biomedical Signal Processing 세션에서 Ack.에 IRB 심의/면제 여부를 적은 경우가 얼마나 되는지를 보기 위해 해당 세션의 논문을 전수 조사해 보았습니다.
결론을 말씀드리자면, EMBC 2015의 논문 제출 가이드라인에도 불구하고 해당 세션에서 발표된 논문 중에 IRB 심의/면제 여부를 Ack에 적은 논문은 단 한 편도 없었습니다. 서울대학교의 판단 결과를 기다려 봐야 하겠지만, 연구 윤리의 판단 기준을 생각하고자 하는 사람은 적어도 그 세션에서 IRB를 언급한 논문이 단 한편도 없었다는 점도 주목을 할 필요가 있다고 생각합니다.
IRB 심의/면제를 바라보는 관점이 학문 분야마다 다를 수 있기 때문에, 바이오/의학 분야의 기준을 무조건 다른 학문 분야에도 적용해야 한다는 생각은 제고해야 할 것 같습니다.
글을 읽는 사람의 공정한 판단을 돕고, IRB를 언급한 논문이 단 한편도 없었다는 저의 주장을 검증할 수 있도록, 논문 PDF 파일의 주소, 논문 제목 및 논문 저자의 소속기관까지 포함된 자료를 아래에 올려 드립니다.
참고한 사이트 목록:
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/
EMBC-2015 Biomedical Signal Processing 세션의 전체 논문 정보
FrFPoT1 Poster Session, Gold Room Add to My Program
1.LB1 Biomedical Signal Processing
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19362849.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.1=
Neurocritical Care Informatics: Leveraging Data and Models to Improve the Care of Brain-Injured Patients
Fanelli, Andrea Massachusetts Inst. of Tech
Heldt, Thomas Massachusetts Inst. of Tech
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19373583.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.2=
SMUAP Decomposition Based on Sequentially-Modified Template Matching Method During Motion
Akazawa, Jun Meiji Univ. of Integrative Medicine
Okuno, Ryuhei Setsunan Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19383122.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.3=
In-Vivo Electrical Impedance Measurement in Mastoid Bone
Wyss Balmer, Thomas Univ. of Berne Inst. of Surgical Tech. and Biomech
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19403603.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.5=
ECG Signal Processing for Heat Rate Extraction
Fedotov, Alexander Samara State Aerospace Univ
Akulova, Anna Samara State Aerospace Univ
Akulov, Sergey Samara State Aerospace Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19413594.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.6=
A Portable Device for Electrogastrography
Budillon, Alessandra Univ. of Naples Parthenope
Grassini, Giuseppe Univ. of Naples Parthenope
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19423402.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.7=
Accelerometer-Based Signal Extraction Algorithm for Obstructive Sleep Apnea Hypopnea Preliminary Screening
Panigrahi, Bivas Chang Gung Univ
Lee, Ming-Yih Chang Gung Univ
Lin, Wen-Yen Chang Gung Univ
Lee, Chung shu Chang Gung Memorial Hospital
Chen, Ning-Hung Chang Gung Memorial Hospital
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19433411.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.8=
Automatic Classification of Saccadic versus Fixation Phases for Head-Free Gaze Shifts Using Supervised Support Vector Machines with Gaussian Kernels
Haji Abolhassani, Iman McGill Univ
Galiana, Henrietta L. McGill Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19443427.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.9=
Machine Learning Based Diagnosis of Schizophrenia Using Combined Sensor-Level and Source-Level EEG Features
Shim, Miseon Hanyang Univ
Kim, Do-Won Hanyang Univ
Lee, Seung Hwan Inje Univ. Ilsanpaik Hospital
Im, Chang-Hwan Hanyang Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19453428.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.10=
Analysis of the Bladder Cancer Transition Mechanism Using a 3D Bladder-On-A-Chip
Lee, Eojin Korea Inst. of Science and Tech
Jeon, Hojeong Korea Inst. of Science and Tech
Kwon, Chunga Korea Inst. of Science and Tech
Park, Jaeho Korea Inst. of Science and Tech
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19463471.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.11=
Time and Frequency Domain Feature Quantification for Snoring Episodes Using Wearable Sensors in Home Environment
Panigrahi, Bivas Chang Gung Univ
Lee, Ming-Yih Chang Gung Univ
Lin, Wen-Yen Chang Gung Univ
Lee, Chung shu Chang Gung Memorial Hospital
Chen, Ning-Hung Chang Gung Memorial Hospital
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19473489.pdf
Sparse Source Separation of High-Density Intramuscular EMG Signals
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.12=
Sparse Source Separation of High-Density Intramuscular EMG Signals
Negro, Francesco Bernstein Center for Computational Neuroscience, Univ
Muceli, Silvia Univ. Medical Center Göttingen
Lin, Chuang Univ. Medical Center Goettingen, Georg-August Univ
Farina, Dario Bernstein Center for Computational Neuroscience, Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19483516.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.13=
Frequency Analysis of Urinary Bladder Pre-Voiding Activity in Normal and Overactive Human Detrusor: A Pilot Study
Zolliker, Daniel Univ. of Bern
Niederhauser, Thomas Bern Univ. of Applied Sciences
Grämiger, Michelle Univ. Für Urologie, Inselspital Bern
van Mastrigt, Ron Erasmus Medical Center
Burkhard, Fiona Univ. Hospital Bern Switzerland
Obrist, Dominik ARTORG Center, Univ. of Bern, Bern
Clavica, Francesco ARTORG Center, Univ. of Bern
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19493539.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.14=
New Adaptive Algorithm to Determine Sleep Onset Latency
Choi, Soo Beom Yonsei Univ
Kim, Sung Woo LG Electronics Advanced Res. Inst
Chung, Jai Won Yonsei Univ
Park, Jee Soo Yonsei Univ. Coll. of Medicine
Noh, Hyung Wook Electronics and Telecommunications Res. Inst
Kim, Deok Won Yonsei Univ. Coll. of Medicine
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19503541.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.15=
A Research on the Feasibility of Cardiac Output Estimation Using Photoplethysmogram and Ballistocardiogram
Kim, Hyun Jo St. Paul's School
Kim, Heejin Seoul National Univ
Ku, Yunseo Seul National Univ. Samsung Advanced Inst. of Tech
Yoon, Hyung-Jin Seoul National Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19513575.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.16=
Reducing the Dimensionality of Brain Signal Using Graph Based Filtering
Liu, Rui Singapore Univ. of Tech. and Design
Nejati, Hossein Sutd.edu.sg
Cheung, Ngai-Man Singapore Univ. of Tech. and Design
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19523640.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.17=
Robust Human Recognition Using Heartbeat Feature
Bashar, Khayrul Ochanomizu Univ
Yoshida, Hiroaki Ochanomizu Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19533722.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.18=
Potential Use of Microsaccade in Personal Identification
Yoneya, Makoto NTT Communication Science Lab
Furukawa, Shigeto Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corp
Kashino, Makio Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corp
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19543645.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.19=
Acoustic Characterization of the Physical Dynamics of Single Phase-Change Droplets
Kang, Shih-Tsung National Tsing Hua Univ
Kao, Wei-Pu Department of Biomedical Engineering and Environmental Sciences,
Yeh, Chih-Kuang National Tsing Hua Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19553647.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.20=
Comparison of Preferences of Kawaii Characters by Eye Tracking between Genders and Generations of Japanese
Ohkura, Michiko Shibaura Inst. of Tech
Iida, Ikumi Shibaura Inst. of Tech
Sano, Hiroya Shibaura Inst. of Tech
Morishita, Wataru Shibaura Inst. of Tech
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19563650.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.21=
Newborn Acute Pain Monitoring Using Heart Rate Variability Analysis
De Jonckheere, Julien CHRU De Lille
Logier, Regis CHRU De Lille
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19573710.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.22=
A Dynamic Harmonic Regression Algorithm for Time-Frequency Analysis of Neurophysiologic Signals
Krishnaswamy, Pavitra Massachusetts Inst. of Tech
Nolan, Michael MIT Inst. for Medical Engineering and Science
Zachs, Daniel Department of Anesthesia, Critical Care and Pain Medicine, Massa
Van Dort, Christa MIT Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences
Brown, Emery MIT
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19583714.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.23=
A Microsaccadic Latency Analysis of the Amblyopic Eye
Kanoh, Yuji Kinki Univ
Kohama, Takeshi Faculty of Biology-Oriented Science and Tech. Kinki Univ
Nakai, Yuma Kinki Univ
Yoshida, Hisashi Kinki Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19593723.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.24=
Effect of Music on Standing Stability
Perdomo, Oscar Julian Univ. Manuela Beltran
Argothy, Rodrigo Esteban Univ. Manuela Beltran
Wilches, Carlos Andres Univ. Manuela Beltran
Perdomo, Cesar Univ. Distrital Francisco José De Caldas
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19603752.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.25=
Estimating Cognitive Performance Change Using Heart Rate Variability
Tsunoda, Keisuke NTT Service Evolution Lab. NTT Corp
Chiba, Akihiro NTT Corp
Chigira, Hiroshi NTT Corp
Ura, Tetsuya NTT Service Evolution Lab
Mizuno, Osamu NTT Service Evolution Lab
Tanaka, Tomohiro NTT Service Evolution Lab
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19613753.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.26=
Changes in Cerebrovascular Time Constant in Response to Lower Body Negative Pressure
Kasprowicz, Magdalena Wroclaw Univ. of Tech
Czosnyka, Marek Univ. of Cambridge
Placek, Michal Marcin Wroclaw Univ. of Tech
Diehl, Rolf R. Krupp Hospital
Haubrich, Christina Aachen Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19623758.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.27=
Noninvasive Assessments of Swallowing Function by Sound Frequency Analysis
Yagi, Naomi Kyoto Univ
Nagami, Shinsuke Kyoto Univ
Ueno, Hiroshi Jcraft Co., Ltd
Yabe, Toru Murata Manufacturing Co., Ltd
Kayashita, Jun Prefectural Univ. of Hiroshima
Lin, Meng-Kuan Hyogo Coll. of Medicine
Oke, Yoshihiko Hyogo Coll. of Medicine
Oku, Yoshitaka Hyogo Coll. of Medicine
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19633764.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.28=
Indices for the Assessment of Glycemic Control Quality Based on Pre-Prandial Glucose Monitoring in Subjects under DPP-4 Inhibitors
Tura, Andrea CNR
Farngren, Johan Department of Clinical Sciences, Lund Univ
Schweizer, Anja Novartis Pharma AG
Foley, James E. Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp
Pacini, Giovanni CNR
Ahrén, Bo Department of Clinical Sciences, Lund Univ
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19643791.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.29=
Standardized Push up During a Physical Examination by Distance, Forces and EMG Analysis
Perdomo, Oscar Julian Univ. Manuela Beltran
Barbon, Cristian UMB
Hakspiel, Sebastian UMB
Hurtado, Carlo UMB
Wilches, Carlos Andres Univ. Manuela Beltran
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19653806.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.30=
Estimating Critical Fusion Frequency from Heart Rate Variability
Chiba, Akihiro NTT Corp
Tsunoda, Keisuke NTT Service Evolution Lab. NTT Corp
Chigira, Hiroshi NTT Corp
Ura, Tetsuya NTT Service Evolution Lab
Mizuno, Osamu NTT Service Evolution Lab
Tanaka, Tomohiro NTT Service Evolution Lab
http://150.162.46.34:8080/embc-2015/papers/19663820.pdf
16:00-17:30, Paper FrFPoT1.31=
Separation of Ambulatory Skin Conductance in Day and Sleep Activities Based on Activity Magnitude and Sleep-Wake Scoring
Sano, Akane Massachusetts Inst. of Tech
Fedor, Szymon Massachusetts Inst. of Tech
Picard, Rosalind Massachusetts Inst. of Tech
Bio일정 프리미엄